Sally Rooney’s new novel, Intermezzo, has garnered high praise from critics, described as “utterly perfect.” This fourth book marks a departure from her usual focus on female protagonists, shifting to the complex dynamics between two grieving brothers—Ivan, a 22-year-old chess player, and Peter, a barrister, each navigating their own age-gap relationships.
Critics have lauded Intermezzo for its emotional depth and humor. The Guardian’s Anthony Cummins called it “truly wonderful,” highlighting Rooney’s deft exploration of grief and romantic entanglements. This work continues Rooney’s exploration of intimacy and communication, yet it is noted to be more “confident” than her previous efforts. The Independent’s Jo Hamya remarked that Rooney “at last discovers the full potential of her prowess,” stating that the patience of her readers yields a “transcendent” reward.
The i’s Anna Bonet echoed this sentiment, describing Intermezzo as “mature and profound,” suggesting it encapsulates Rooney’s artistic journey. However, Bonet also points out that while it is a “marvel,” it is not without its flaws. Notably, the character of Naomi, one of Peter’s love interests, feels underdeveloped, a sentiment shared by the Financial Times’ Shahidha Bari. Bari critiques the portrayal of secondary female characters, arguing they fall into familiar archetypes, such as the “Manic Pixie Dream Girl.”
Despite these critiques, Bari acknowledges that Rooney’s writing in Intermezzo is more impressionistic than in her earlier works, offering a fresh perspective on character dialogue and interaction. Rooney herself has expressed that she does not feel pressured to center male voices in her narratives. In an interview with the New York Times, she emphasized her focus on crafting each story as its own unique entity, stating, “I don’t care about my career. I think about how to make this book the perfect version of what it can be.”
While many reviewers agree that Intermezzo represents a significant step forward for Rooney, New Statesman’s Lola Seaton argues it lacks the “taut self-assurance” seen in Conversations with Friends and Normal People. However, she recognizes it as an “honorable, tenacious” effort to break from her established style.
Rooney’s previous novels have not only captivated readers but have also been successfully adapted for television, with Conversations with Friends airing in 2022 and the award-winning Normal People becoming a cultural phenomenon during the pandemic.
In summary, Intermezzo stands out as a compelling exploration of grief and relationships, affirming Rooney’s status as a significant voice in contemporary literature. The novel’s blend of humor, tenderness, and intricate character dynamics offers readers a rich and engaging experience, solidifying Rooney’s reputation for insightful storytelling.