Matteo Salvini’s kidnapping trial: verdict expected this Friday
4 min read
Matteo Salvini, Italy’s Deputy Prime Minister and leader of the Eurosceptic League party, is awaiting the verdict in his kidnapping trial, which stems from his actions in 2019 when he blocked around 100 migrants from disembarking a rescue vessel. The incident occurred while Salvini was serving as the country’s interior minister, a role in which he adopted a tough stance on migration. The verdict, expected this Friday, could have significant legal consequences, potentially leading to a prison sentence of up to six years.
The case involves the 2019 standoff between Salvini’s government and the Open Arms rescue ship, which had rescued 150 migrants, some from the Maltese search and rescue zone. The ship was unable to dock in Italy, despite Lampedusa being the nearest port. The migrants remained stranded in international waters for ten days and then anchored off Lampedusa for another five days. Conditions aboard the ship deteriorated rapidly as migrants grew increasingly restless, some attempting to jump overboard, and minors were eventually evacuated. Despite this, Salvini, who was serving as interior minister at the time, refused to let them disembark.
Salvini’s defense, however, insists that his actions were necessary for protecting Italy’s borders, maintaining national dignity, and upholding the law. Speaking at a rally last week, Salvini boldly declared that “protecting borders, upholding dignity, enforcing laws, and maintaining a nation’s honor can never be deemed a crime.” If convicted of kidnapping for preventing the migrants from disembarking, Salvini could face a prison sentence of up to six years. A sentence of more than five years would also disqualify him from holding public office.
However, even if the verdict is guilty, the decision will not be immediate. Italian law allows for a multi-stage appeal process, meaning that any ruling would not be final until after two levels of appeal, which could take several years.
This trial is just one example of Salvini’s controversial approach to migration during his tenure as interior minister. At the time, under the leadership of Prime Minister Giuseppe Conte’s first government, Salvini implemented strict policies, denying humanitarian rescue vessels access to Italy’s ports and accusing aid organizations of aiding human traffickers. His policies sparked strong reactions, including one notable incident in June 2019 when Carola Rackete, the German captain of the Sea-Watch 3 rescue vessel, defied Salvini’s orders and entered Lampedusa’s port. Rackete had been carrying 40 migrants who had been stranded at sea for nearly 16 days. Salvini’s government initially charged Rackete with facilitating illegal migration, but those charges were later withdrawn.
At the time of the Open Arms incident, Salvini’s approach had widespread backing from his party and supporters who viewed his hardline stance as necessary to curb migration. However, his actions have been criticized by others who argue that he overstepped his authority. Arturo Salerni, the defense attorney for Open Arms, expressed skepticism about Salvini’s motivations in a recent interview with the Associated Press. Salerni contended that an interior minister cannot legally restrict anyone’s freedom without an order from judicial authorities, noting that Salvini’s actions disregarded both international and national laws.
Salvini’s trial is unfolding in Palermo, and the far-right government of Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni, in office since 2022, has expressed strong support for him. Meloni’s government has adopted a similarly tough stance on migration, further aligning with Salvini’s policies. Meloni has focused on tightening migration controls, including forging agreements with North African countries to curb migrant departures and setting up processing centers in Albania for migrants rescued at sea. These efforts are part of her broader strategy to reduce migration flows into Italy, an issue that remains highly contentious in Italian politics.
As Salvini faces the final stages of his trial, his political future hangs in the balance. If convicted, the repercussions could be significant, both for his career and for his party’s standing in Italy’s political landscape. While Salvini has continued to defend his actions as necessary for protecting Italy, critics argue that his approach has undermined international norms and human rights.
Whatever the outcome of the trial, it will be a key moment in Italy’s ongoing debate over migration, the balance between national security and humanitarian concerns, and the role of the government in managing these complex issues. Salvini’s trial, set against the backdrop of Italy’s evolving political landscape, highlights the ongoing divide over how the country should handle the migration crisis, and it will undoubtedly shape the country’s future policies in the years to come.
About The Author
